Contact Us

Welcome to ineedhits Blog

Welcome to the ineedhits Search Engine Marketing blog, where we share the latest search engine and online marketing news, releases, industry trends and great DIY tips and advice.

Thursday, August 18, 2005

Does a Bigger Index mean a Better Index?

Posted by @ 11:33 pm

Yahoo! recently announced that they have indexed 20 billion objects within its index. My colleague Nancy Hackett, recently wrote about this announcement in her article Search Engine Technology: Yahoo! – 20 Billion Objects Indexed . To compare this to the “mere” 8.2 billion web pages indexed by rival Google.

Whilst this makes for great PR for Yahoo! (public relations and not page rank) it doesn’t do necessarily do anything for the consumer. The consumer being the person who is typing in the keywords and expecting a quality result. A bigger search engine index does not necessarily mean a quality search engine index. In fact, I would say that is it quite opposite.

Just having an object in the search engine index doesn’t make it a quality object. If it isn’t a quality object, it is highly unlikely to ever be presented in the results to the user. i.e. deemed irrelevant or so poorly optimized that it ranks in the bottom 10% of the SERPS.

It also does not surprise me that Yahoo! have managed to increase their index size. Yahoo! Slurp (the hybrid best of breed spider technology which grew out of the Inktomi, AltaVista and Fast spiders) has been very aggressive of late and requesting many pages from servers around the world.

Further more, Yahoo! has one huge advantage over Google. Through Yahoo! Search Submit Pro, Yahoo! is provided with many tens of thousand of pages that it might never have found during traditional crawling methods. Google does not have – and according to all of their statements on public record – will never have, a Paid Inclusion program. This does put Google at a disadvantage in the bragging rights over whose index is bigger.

The most accurate measure (I believe) is on search user satisfaction, which according to the latest study is still Google. Although the gap is narrowing with Yahoo catching up to Google, with a score of 80 out of 100, verus the Google score of 82%.

This reinforces my point that many of the extra objects in the Yahoo! index are adding no value, other than bragging rights. So is often the case, bigger doesn’t mean better.

Note: an object is defined as being either a web page, an image or any other file type (video, MP3 etc).

Tags: ,

Discussion (2 - comments)

This is Jerry Mac with The Country Music Planet located on the internet at . I definitely believe that yahoo gives much more up to date results than google does. For example, when searching for country music singers at google a site come up number two that han’t been updated since 2003, we come up number 5, and I don’t mind the other 3 being in front of us at google, because they are very relevant, but for this site to be at number 2 is rediculous. when i search for country music singers at yahoo, we come up number one and we should, because we are the most relative site on Planet Earth when it comes to country music singers.

By Jerry Mac - August 23, 2005

Jerry Reynolds Advertising Services, Ltd.
My site offering graphic arts and printing for the past five
had enjoyed a respectable placement at Google, Yahoo, and MSN
within the top 50 placements for most key words. April of this
year out of the blue Google bounced us to the basement.
Example; Catalog Sheet Printing
Google: 884
Yahoo: 10
MSN: 6
This resulted in a little over 50% reduction in traffic
Yesterday: Catalog Sheet Printing
Google: 850
Yahoo: 1
MSN: 1
We have recovered 45% of that lost traffic in the past 4 months
without Google.

By Jerry - August 23, 2005

Add Your Comments


Keep up to date with the latest from our blogs.

Subscribe to all blog posts

The Newsletter

  • New Posts
  • Popular
  • Comments


More in Search News (1757 of 1797 articles)

MIVA, formerly, has settled a long-running legal dispute with Yahoo!'s Overture Services. The dispute centered on patented technology that ...